Delhi HC Opens Gate For Students From Open School To Take NEET, Upholds CBSE’s Age Limit Of 25 Yrs [Read Judgment]

In a major development, the Delhi High Court on Friday said students from open school can also take the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET) while upholding the CBSE’s upper age limit of 25 and 30 years for general and reserved categories, respectively, to apply for the pre-Medical test considering the limited number of seats and large number of aspirants in India. A bench of Justice Sanjiv Khanna and Justice Chander Shekhar dismissed the petitions challenging the age limit while hoping that age and subject restrictions would not be required in near future.

The bench was of the view that the MCI has “proceeded on prejudice and assumption or a priori ex hypothesis predicated on the belief the students/candidates who do not attend regular schools, because of financial hardship and social reasons, are inferior and less deserving and turn downs. Such presumptions must be resoundingly rejected as contrary to the constitutional ethos and would clearly violate both Article 14 and right to opportunity to acquire professional degree”.

“NEET is a centralized and a single window examination, conducted in a transparent manner. This is a true and sure test of competence, caliber and aptitude. Professional degree would be awarded to students who meet the exacting standards and qualify the MBBS course. Impugned prohibition in the form of disqualification of students/candidates of open school Board is therefore disproportionate and unreasonable to the purported evil sought to be remedied, i.e. to filter out students who are not interested and do not have the caliber and intellect to undergo and clear the MBBS course,” it observed.

The court went on to add that, “[h]igher level of knowledge is liberating, enabling and empowering to those who suffer from prejudice and are financially challenged. Efforts have to be made and law must permit inclusion and not exclusion of such persons from portals of knowledge. Indian Constitution recognizes the affirmative action as an extension of the principle of equality. It would be unfair and unjust if we on vague and unsubstantiated pretence of unfitness close the door of knowledge on candidates, who have done class 12 from open school Boards. The restrictions envisaged would not only be unreasonable but would perpetuate inequality and hamper promotion of egalitarian social order and justice”.

“… we would accept that every person should be given an opportunity to compete for selection for neither age nor subjects studied in school matter, when the person has competence and calibre clear the entrance examination and successfully complete the MBBS course. Multidisciplinary approach in medicine and other fields is now accepted as necessary and beneficial.There are several countries that do not subscribe any restriction on age limit or the course/subjects studied during schooling without sacrificing quality and calibre.

“However, in the present context and background in India, given the limited number of seats and large number of aspirants, it is difficult to hold that the upper age limit is not a reasonable restriction, which has been imposed in the interest of general public. Hopefully, in near future, this situation would change, and age and―subject constraint and restriction would not be required and necessary,” said the bench.

While dismissing the challenge to the age limit for NEET, the court noted that one of the petitions seeking age relaxation was filed by Ritinath Shukla, a 45-year-old ward boy who wished to become a doctor.

“…Petitioner submits that they should be given preference and they want to upgrade their skills as a compounder/ward boy to that of a qualified doctor. We can empathize with the desire of Ritinath Shukla to appear in the NEET examination to qualify to selection to a medical college, but do not think this can be a ground to allow the writ petition and grant relief.

The bench further said, “…need to put the upper age limit was necessary as there are approximately 61000 seats for MBBS course in government and private medical colleges in the country. There has to be a level playing field for selection amongst lakhs of candidates who appear every year (in 2017, about 11 lakh candidates had appeared). It is obvious that a candidate who is 17 or 18 years of age will find it difficult to compete with a candidate who is above 26/31 years of age and has been studying for last 7 to 10 years or even more only to get admission to an MBBS course,” the court noted.

Conclusion

(a) Proviso to clause 4(2)(a) of the Regulations disqualifying recognized open school Board candidates is struck down and declared unconstitutional. Students/candidates, who have done class 12 from NIOS or recognized open school State Boards, would not be treated as per se disqualified for selection and appearance in NEET. Their NEET results, when otherwise eligible, would be declared with other candidates.

(b)Proviso to clause 4 prescribing upper age limit of 25 years in case of general category candidates and 30 years in case of reserved category candidates is legal and valid. To this extent, the writ petitions challenging vires of proviso to clause 4 of the Regulations are dismissed.

(c) In respect of private students, MCI has already issued a clarification, which appears to have satisfied grievance of the private candidates. In the light of the said clarification, no arguments have been addressed before us and, therefore, we have not decided or adjudicated on the said issue/aspect, the court said.

Source Credits: LiveLaw

Resonance Eduventures Ltd. A premiere coaching institute in the field of Engineering, Medical, Commerce and Law.
2974 Selections in NEET 2017 from Resonance.
NEET Web Banner

Admission open for Academic Session 2018-19 for class 5th to 12th. To Apply now, click here

NEET UG 2018 On May 6; Last Minute Preparation Tips By Expert

The countdown to NEET UG 2018 exam has begun. With barely 6 days left for the exam, it is natural for aspirants to feel nervous and anxious. NEET is the one stop gateway to prestigious medical colleges in the country. Hence, the preparation for NEET examination requires a well-planned strategy both for the short and medium term. With approximately 13.36 lakh students registering for the examination, it is extremely crucial to not only crack the exam but also secure a good rank.

Here are a few important last minute tips given by Mr. Rohit Manglik, CEO, EduGorilla, which will help you ace the examination easily:

Study with short breaks: Studying for 12-14 hours at a stretch can lead to mental fatigue. Focus on quality of study rather than just the number of hours put in. It is advisable to take short breaks and relax your mind with light music or games.

Brush up basics:  A deep study of NCERT books is highly recommended. If you have prepared notes from NCERT, ensure you revise them thoroughly. Since there is a small gap between board and NEET examination, build on your board examination preparation.

Avoid reading any new topic or study material: With the ocean of study material available, it is common for students to fall prey to a new study material just a few days before the examination. Refrain from doing it. This will not only increase your stress level but also make you difficult to retain information learned at the last moment.

Strike the right balance: The study sessions should be a mix of theory, problem-solving and revising all previous years’ papers. Equal emphasis should be given to all subjects.

Revise concepts and formulae: Ensure that you devote ample time in revising important concepts and formulae. This will help you retain information better and boost your confidence.
result-NEET-2017dfg

2974 Selections in NEET 2017 from Resonance.

Admission open for Academic Session 2018-19 for class 5th to 12th. To Apply now, click here

Know the focus areas: It is equally important to pay attention to selected topics. These are:-

  • Physics: Mechanics, Optics, Thermodynamics and Nuclear Physics
  • Chemistry – Mole Concept, General Organic Chemistry, Periodic Table, Chemical Bonding, Coordination Chemistry
  • Biology- Ecology and Environment, Genetics, Cell Biology, Morphology, Reproduction and Physiology of Plants and Animals, Basics of Biotechnology

Take mock tests in exam -simulated environment: Try to take mock tests to get into the groove and muster the art of time management. Stick to the time-limit and try to improve your performance with every mock test. It is better that you take mock tests at the examination timings to make yourself habituated to taking the examination at that time. After every mock test, analyze your performance. Work on your weak areas during the time of revision.

Keep calm and beat anxiety: Try to keep calm. Remember this is just another phase of life. Try to relax in a way that suits you- yoga, meditation, talking to friends over the phone, playing with your pets. Good Luck!

Source Credit: NDTV

Single Common Entrance Test (CET) for MBBS aspirants across India

The Medical Council of India (MCI) decided to conduct single common entrance test (CET) for medical aspirants from across the country for MBBS and MD. The MCI has sent their recommendation to the ministry of health and family planning and is awaiting its approval. MCI said it is expecting the government to approve the proposal so that it can it can be implemented in the coming academic year.

There are around 70,000 seats for MBBS and 21,000 seats for MD in institutions across India. Currently, every state government conduct their own entrance test. Similarly, private medical college association, deemed universities and minority institutes who offer medical education too conduct their own CET. Candidates most often take all these tests as they don’t want to risk their chances. Last time, the MCI had lost the case in the court on technical grounds. Continue reading

The Union Cabinet cleared proposals to set up three new All India Institutes of Medical Sciences (AIIMS)

The Cabinet on Wednesday approved proposals for setting up 3 new All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) in Nagpur (Maharashtra.), Mangalgiri (Andhra Pradesh) and Kalyani (West Bengal) under Pradhan Mantri Swasthya Suraksha Yojna (PMSSY) at a of cost of Rs 4,949 crore. Continue reading

RE-AIPMT 2015: A Detailed Analysis by Resonance Expert Team

RE-AIPMT – 2015

A Detailed Analysis (Cut-off, Answer Key, Solution and Subject-Wise Discussion) by Resonance

On 25th July- 2015, AIPMT-2015 (Re-Test) was conducted for entrance into state and national level medical colleges for MBBS, BDS courses under strict supervision as the original edition was cancelled by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India due to a high-tech cheating racket exposed at various part of India. Last exam was conducted on 03rd May-2015. The pattern and syllabus of exam remained same as that that of previous one. Around 6.35 Lakh students are stated to appear for this exam.

Continue reading

AIPMT 2015: A Detailed Analysis by Resonance Expert Team

AIPMT – 2015

A Detailed Analysis (Cut-off, Answer Key, Solution and Subject-Wise Discussion) by Resonance

On 03-May-2015, AIPMT-2015 was conducted for entrance into state and national level medical colleges for MBBS, BDS, BAMS, BHS courses. This is the second edition of this exam after changes were introduced in year 2014 by CBSE and Ministry of HRD. Around 6 Lakh students appeared for this exam.

Continue reading